Study says no amount of alcohol is truly risk-free: time to quit?
2 · Read
Welcome to RoundTalk. A new study says no amount of alcohol is truly safe. Should Americans quit drinking, or is that claim too strong? With us: Marcus, an emergency room doctor; Diane, a food journalist; and Robert, a recovered alcoholic and counselor.
Marcus, what does the Shield and Keyes study tell you that you don't already know?
It tells me nothing new, and that's exactly why the guidelines ignoring it bothers me. Last month I admitted a 41-year-old with liver failure. Two glasses of wine a night, he said. He thought that was the safe amount.
Diane, did the alcohol industry actually lobby to keep Shield and Keyes out of the new guidelines?
There's no proof of lobbying. There's an editorial by Robert Vincent saying it was sidelined. That's different. And one modeling study shouldn't set federal policy alone — that's the rule I'd want applied to industry research too.
Robert, does a warning like Shield and Keyes actually move someone, or does it just add guilt?
It adds guilt, mostly. People don't quit because of a study. I drank through plenty of warnings. What moved me was my daughter, age nine, asking why I slept on the couch.
No, wait — studies don't move the drinker, sure. But they move the number on the label, the doctor's script, the guidelines. My 41-year-old wasn't ignoring a warning. Nobody ever gave him one.
Diane, how do you see it?
He'd heard the warnings for years — he just didn't believe them.
Heard what, exactly? "Limit alcoholic beverages." That's the current federal wording — no number at all. He believed two a day was fine because that's what the old guidelines said. Vague advice isn't a warning people can act on.
Sorry, but — I had a doctor in 2011 tell me to "cut back." Cut back from what? I went home and poured the same drink. A number would have scared me. "Limit" gave me room to argue.
Key vocabulary
- mortality — death or the death rate in a population
- modeling — creating a mathematical or statistical representation
- sidelined — pushed to the side or excluded from consideration
- drinker — a person who drinks alcohol
- alcoholic — relating to alcohol or a person dependent on alcohol
- certainty — the state of being certain or completely sure
Comprehension questions
- Why does Marcus think the new guidelines should address the Shield and Keyes study?
- What does Diane say about the claim that the alcohol industry lobbied against the Shield and Keyes study?
- According to Robert, what made him stop drinking rather than scientific studies?
- How does Marcus explain why his 41-year-old patient drank two glasses of wine every night?
True or false?
- Marcus admits a patient who drank three glasses of wine per night and developed liver failure. T / F
- Diane believes that one modeling study alone should not set federal policy. T / F
- Robert stopped drinking after reading the Shield and Keyes study. T / F
Fill the gaps
- With us: Marcus, an emergency room doctor; Diane, a food journalist; and Robert, a recovered and counselor.
- There's an editorial by Robert Vincent saying it was .
- And one study shouldn't set federal policy alone — that's the rule I'd want applied to industry research too.
- No, wait — studies don't move the , sure.
Discuss in pairs
- If guidelines clearly stated 'do not drink more than one glass per day,' do you think more people would follow them, or would they still ignore them like Robert's patient did?
- Marcus says studies affect policy and labels, not just individual drinkers. Do you think changing the law is more important than convincing people to change their own behaviour?
- Robert's daughter's question was more powerful than any study. What other personal situations or relationships do you think could motivate people to make healthier choices better than facts and warnings?
The whole debate, free every day Students can hear the full 6-minute episode with a synced transcript in the RoundTalk app.
Get it on Google Play Download on the App StoreAnswer key
Comprehension- Because vague advice like 'limit alcoholic beverages' doesn't give people a specific number to follow, so they believe their own interpretation of what is safe.
- There is no proof of actual lobbying; there is only an editorial saying it was sidelined, which is different.
- His nine-year-old daughter asking him why he slept on the couch.
- Because the old guidelines said two glasses a day was safe, and nobody gave him a clear warning that this amount was risky.
- False
- True
- False
- alcoholic
- sidelined
- modeling
- drinker
roundtalk · https://www.getroundtalk.com/listen/english/b2/study-says-no-amount-of-alcohol-is-truly-risk-free-time-to-quit/worksheet/