Airlines keep avoiding Dubai flights over regional tension: too cautious?
2 · Read
Welcome to RoundTalk. Eight months ago, strikes closed Dubai's airport. Now, foreign airlines are still staying away—but Gulf carriers keep flying. Should we trust them, or are they taking real risks? Margaret Chen, airline safety expert. Rajesh Kapoor, former pilot. Sophie Leclerc, travel journalist.
Margaret, what's different this time?
I'd fly Emirates tomorrow, and I'd still say the foreign carriers aren't wrong. Cathay and Singapore aren't reading a different sky. They're reading a different insurance policy. That's the real gap.
No, no, wait. It's not the insurance. It's planning. Emirates and flydubai found new ways around Iranian airspace in a weekend. Cathay and KLM couldn't. That's a hub which doesn't move fast.
Sophie, if hub speed is the real issue, why are Cathay's bookings to Dubai still falling eight months later?
Couldn't? They could. British Airways came back this month, Lufthansa comes back next week. Same airspace, same planes. So it isn't planning. KLM just picked a later date, because nobody wants the liability if something goes wrong.
Liability is the excuse, not the reason — they weren't ready.
Sorry, but no. Liability isn't an excuse, it's the whole machine. I read every claim my firm processes. If the insurer won't cover that airspace, the airline simply cannot fly. That's not slowness.
Hang on, hang on. An insurer doesn't decide the sky. It prices what you bring them. Emirates still keeps Tel Aviv suspended, and Riyadh too — so they say no when it matters. That's judgement, not a machine.
Sophie, if Emirates picks and chooses which routes to risk, what does that tell you about their safety calls?
Key vocabulary
- airspace — sky or air above a country or region
- flydubai — low-cost airline based in Dubai
- liability — legal responsibility for harm or loss
- Iranian — relating to Iran or its people
- hub — central point where routes or services connect
Comprehension questions
- Why does Margaret Chen say foreign airlines like Cathay are not flying to Dubai?
- What does Rajesh Kapoor believe is the real reason airlines are staying away from Dubai?
- Why does Sophie think KLM is choosing not to return to Dubai yet?
- What does Margaret say an airline must have before it can fly to a risky airspace?
- According to Rajesh, how does Emirates show that airlines can choose which risks to take?
True or false?
- Margaret Chen believes that insurance policies, not planning speed, are the main reason some airlines avoid Dubai. T / F
- Rajesh Kapoor claims that Emirates and flydubai were able to change their routes around Iranian airspace very quickly. T / F
- Margaret Chen says that insurance companies decide which airports are safe for airlines to fly to. T / F
Fill the gaps
- Emirates and flydubai found new ways around Iranian in a weekend.
- That's a which doesn't move fast.
- KLM just picked a later date, because nobody wants the if something goes wrong.
Discuss in pairs
- If you were an airline manager, would you follow Emirates' speed and return to Dubai quickly, or wait like KLM and British Airways? Why?
- Do you think airlines should be allowed to choose their own risks, or should governments and insurance companies make these decisions? Who should decide?
- Is it fair for passengers to book flights that airlines themselves think are too dangerous? What should airlines tell customers before they fly to risky places?
The whole debate, free every day Students can hear the full 6-minute episode with a synced transcript in the RoundTalk app.
Get it on Google Play Download on the App StoreAnswer key
Comprehension- Because their insurance policies do not allow them to fly in that airspace.
- They cannot plan new routes around Iranian airspace quickly enough, unlike Emirates.
- Because KLM wants to avoid the legal responsibility if something bad happens on that route.
- The airline must have insurance cover from an insurer for that airspace.
- Emirates stops flying to some dangerous cities like Tel Aviv and Riyadh when they decide it is not safe.
- True
- True
- True
- airspace
- hub
- liability
roundtalk · https://www.getroundtalk.com/listen/english/b1/airlines-keep-avoiding-dubai-flights-over-regional-tension-too/worksheet/